Top 6 Wave Payroll Competitors and Alternatives for 2023

Gusto: Best for well-rounded payroll software

Gusto payroll software provides an all-around solid alternative to Wave. For instance, Gusto may not be the cheapest payroll software or have the most HR features, but it does have competitive pricing and plenty of HR features. So even if Gusto isn’t the best at every single thing, it’s very good at a whole lot.

Likewise, Gusto’s plans range from the payroll-focused Simple to the feature-rich Premium, with each tier offering a clear upgrade to features and value. That means Gusto can comfortably work for businesses that have simple payroll needs as well as businesses looking to tackle more difficult payroll and HR needs ― and there’s a good chance Gusto can work for your business.

Features

• Payroll, benefits and talent management tools.
• Many software integrations.
• Time and project tracking solutions.
• Lifetime employee access.

Pros

• Excellent self-service tools for employees.
• Plentiful HR and benefit features.
• Automation for payroll and ledger.
• Contractor-only plan.

Cons

• Few features on cheapest plan.
• Expensive higher-tier plans.
• No weekend customer support.

Pricing

Gusto offers four different plan tiers:

• Simple plan: $40 per month plus another $6 per payee.
• Plus plan: $80 per month plus another $12 per payee.
• Premium plan: Enterprise plan with custom pricing.
• Contractor Only plan: $35 per month plus $6 per contractor.

You can also add on extras like international contractor payments, 401(k) savings, commuter benefits and more for an additional fee.

For more information, read the full Gusto review.

OnPay: Best for industry-specific payroll

While most businesses can get by with one-size-fits-all payroll software, sometimes it’s nice to use a software company that gets your specific industry ― which is just how OnPay operates. 

Take employee pay, for instance. OnPay can easily deal with the wage tip makeup and multiple pay rates that are unique to restaurants. Or look at taxes. OnPay understands different industries have different requirements, so it will take care of agriculture-specific Form 943 for your farm or ranch. OnPay’s industry expertise makes payroll services simpler for you.

Even setting that aside, OnPay is a solid payroll software. It doesn’t charge extra fees (including common ones, like for wage garnishment). It has a good number of HR, benefits and attendance management tools. That makes it a good option for any business ― and a better option for businesses with specialized niche payroll needs.

Features

• Payroll services tailored to various industries.
• Benefit management, onboarding and other HR tools.
• Integrations with popular accounting software.
• Add-on insurance brokerage in all 50 states.

Pros

• Fewer add-on fees than other payroll software.
• Free white glove setup.
• Payroll expertise for many industries.

Cons

• One plan only with limited scalability.
• No option for automated payments.
• No support for international payees.

Pricing

OnPay has very simple pricing, with just one plan:

• $40 per month plus another $6 per payee.

That plan includes all its features, so you won’t get hit with extra fees for certain tools. Plus, OnPay lets you get your first month for free.

For more information, read the full OnPay review.

Patriot Payroll: Best for first-time payroll

If you’ve got a brand-new business or you just hired your first employees, Patriot Payroll offers an excellent introduction to payroll software. First off, the self-service tax plan makes Patriot highly affordable ― perfect for businesses without much budget wiggle room. And while Payroll doesn’t offer all the features of pricier payroll software, it does have options for essentials like 401(k) integrations and time tools. In other words, you can get the important tools without getting overwhelmed by other features.

Payroll also provides free white glove setup, so Patriot will do a lot of the legwork for you. Plus, customers have rave reviews about Patriot’s customer service, which means you should have no trouble getting help as you start your payroll journey.

Features

• Self-service or full-service payroll plans.
• Self-service portals for employees.
• No-cost integrations with external 401(k) plans.
• Optional add-ons for time and attendance and HR tools.

Pros

• Highly affordable self-service payroll plan.
• Free setup wizard or white glove setup.
• Very positive customer service reviews.

Cons

• Limited options for scaling with just two plans.
• Few HR features compared to competitors.
• Just one software integration (for QuickBooks Online).

Pricing

Patriot has two payroll plans:

• Basic Payroll plan: $17 per month plus another $4 per payee.
• Full Service Payroll plan: $37 per month plus another $4 per payee.

The Basic plan requires you to take care of your own payroll taxes, while the Full Service plan does taxes for you. You can try either plan free for 30 days.

For more information, read the full Patriot Payroll review.

Paychex Flex: Best for HR solutions

If you wish Wave included HR tools along with payroll, then you might like Paychex Flex. It offers all the payroll tools your business could need, but Paychex also gives you access to a full suite of HR features too. It has benefits management, for instance, including less-common benefits like financial wellness programs. And some plans include tools like a learning management system, perfect for keeping your team on the same page with thorough documentation.

All its tools make Paychex a great fit for even very large companies. But with several different tiers of plans, Paychex can work for much smaller startups too. It can scale with your business, giving you both the payroll and the HR solutions you need.

Features

• Payroll, benefits, HR and workforce management tools.
• Multiple employee pay options, including tip disbursement and pay cards.
• Comprehensive HR features, such as handbook wizard and learning management system.
• Apps for both employees and employers.

Pros

• Strong customer service, with 24/7 customer support and a dedicated contact.
• Huge library of HR documents, labor posters and other resources.
• Wide range of benefit options available as add-ons.

Cons

• Above-average plan costs for higher-tier plans.
• General ledger integration limited to paid add-on.
• Extra fees for software integrations.

Pricing

Paychex Flex lets you choose from three plans:

• Essentials plan: Starts at $39 per month plus another $5 per payee.
• Select plan: Custom pricing.
• Pro plan: Custom pricing.

The Essentials plan has all the basic payroll features,while the Select plan adds on a learning management system (LMS). If you want talent management, workforce management and top-tier payroll features, you’ll need the Pro plan.

For more information, read the full Paychex Flex review.

RUN Powered by ADP: Best for larger businesses

For businesses that need more than Wave can offer ― more payroll tools, more HR features, more solutions for data analysis ― we suggest RUN Powered by ADP.  It has more advanced payroll tools, like multi-jurisdictional payroll (complete with taxes for different states). ADP also offers lots of HR tools, including features for background checks and recruiting. You can even get marketing tools with your payroll plan.

Throw in add-ons like attendance, retirement, workers’ comp and health insurance tools, and you’ve got pretty much everything your big business could want from a payroll software. And as an added bonus, ADP offers 24/7 customer support, so you can get prompt help and keep your business on track.

Features

• Payroll-focused or payroll-with-HR plans.
• Powerful, customizable payroll and HR reporting tools.
• Add-ons for time, retirement, workers’ comp and marketing.

Pros

• Payroll support for 140 countries.
• Uncommon features like employee discounts and background checks on all plans.
• Many software integrations available on ADP Marketplace.

Cons

• No pricing information available online.
• Steep learning curve compared to simpler software.
• Most HR features limited to highest-tier plan.

Pricing

ADP doesn’t offer any pricing information online. You’ll need to get in touch with a rep (via its website or over the phone) to get custom payroll pricing for your company.

For more information, read the full ADP review.

SurePayroll: Best for affordability

If even Wave feels like a stretch for your budget, consider SurePayroll instead. It’s one of the cheapest payroll software tools out there, with a self-service plan under $20 per month and a full-service plan under $30 per month. Even the per-payee cost is lower than you see with most software, with $4 or $5 per month instead of $6.

Don’t worry, though ― SurePayroll doesn’t skimp on what matters. You still get core payroll tools, plus features like payroll automation and extended customer support hours. And SurePayroll is owned by Paychex (reviewed above), so you know it’s a trustworthy product even with the bargain pricing.

Features

• Full-service and DIY tax filing plans.
• Payroll automation, including benefit deductions.
• Tax calculations and calculation guarantee with self-service plan.

Pros

• Up to six months free over your first year.
• Saturday customer support hours.
• Option to add benefits like 401(k) and health insurance.

Cons

• Fewer reporting tools than other payroll software.
• Separate additional charges for accounting integrations and timeclock integrations.
• Just two plans with relatively few included features.

Pricing

SurePayroll has two plans, with the difference coming down to taxes:

• Self-service plan: $19.99 per month plus another $4 per payee per month.
• Full-service plan: $29.99 per month plus another $5 per payee per month.

As an added benefit, you can get up to six months of SurePayroll for free. It’s not a six-month trial, though ― instead you’ll alternate paid and free months over your first year.

For more information, read the full SurePayroll review.